Noel Rappin Writes Here


Posted on April 18, 2008

sf tv

Battlestar Galactica 402ish “Six of One”

Some quick bullet points before the next one comes down the pike.

Very pleased with the first two episodes of the season – I think it’s encouraging that this episode, credited to a writer whose last couple were not that strong, was arguably better than the first.

  • Katee Sackhoff had an amazing week – Starbuck was all over the place, on the very edge of hysteria of not past it, a lot of great scenes. The Adama/Roslin scenes were also very good.

  • If you are looking for a line to take a something other than face value, I’d recommend “I’m no more a Cylon then you are”

  • How long can Tigh, Anders, Tory, and Tyrol meet together before somebody gets suspicious? It’s not like they travel in the same social circles or that anybody is going to believe they’ve got a bridge game going…

  • Loved the Cylon civil war idea – it’s very consistent with what Moore has said in a number of interviews about Cylon society being young and under it’s first real stress. (This is actually where I thought they were going to go at the end of Season Two, after “Downloaded” first hinted at pro and anti human politics among the Cylons. Plus it’s always nice to see Dean Stockwell. (The actual confrontation scene was capped by Tricia Helfer’s look of shock at the end.)

  • Okay, having two farewell ceremonies for Lee was a bit much, especially since you’d think that there would be some resentment over an able-bodied person leaving the military. That said, both scenes worked on their own, and I thought the aside in the bar scene of the group presumably strip poker was weird and funny.

  • There are many reasons I like this show. One is that Baltar, after the events of last episode, still had a visible scar in this episode – a point that many shows would ignore. Watching Callis play against himself was also fun.


comments powered by Disqus

Copyright 2024 Noel Rappin

All opinions and thoughts expressed or shared in this article or post are my own and are independent of and should not be attributed to my current employer, Chime Financial, Inc., or its subsidiaries.